I definitely prefer my eyes to be a blend of cartoon-y maxis-match and realism. It's mostly the sclera that I need to be more on the realistic side - I hate the bright white corners of most maxis-match sclera.

And size, yes! I like my eyes to just hit the bottom lid. The originals by NeenaNeedles were too big, and Medinaquirin's were just a bit too small... mine are a nice happy medium. :)

I'm glad you like them. :D